Alternatives
to Toxic Termite Control
August, 2004
Environmental Health Coalition does
not endorse any products or services. Although we have made every
effort to verify that the information is complete and current, there
may be additional alternatives or companies that we have inadvertently
left out
When
Do You Need Termite Treatment?
According to the Northwest Coalition
for Alternatives to Pesticides, a large drywood colony consumes about
half a pound of wood per year, and it takes seven years for a colony
to develop to this size.1 This means you have time to evaluate
options for prevention and treatment before taking action.
This fact sheet includes a summary of
termite eradication options as well as prevention options. EHC always
recommends prevention as the first and foremost approach to dealing
with any pest problem. However, if you are a tenant or a condo dweller,
you may be in a situation where someone else is proposing to fumigate
your home. In this case, the termite eradication alternatives may
be the information you need immediately for avoiding fumigation.
|
What’s
Wrong with Conventional Chemical Treatments?
Exterminators
commonly rely on Vikane (sulfuryl fluoride) for whole fumigation
and Dursban (chlorpyrifos) for spot treatment. Both are toxic
to the nervous system if people are exposed. Young, old, ill,
and chemically sensitive people are at special risk. Tear gas
(chloropicrin) is often used as a warning agent. Chloropicrin
causes eye and respiratory tract irritation and vomiting.
Problems
and uncertainties with chemical fumigation:
-
Applicator
error happens. Excessive amounts are sometimes applied;
-
Even if the house is cleared for re-entry, there may be
pockets of higher levels, or levels may build up again once
the house is closed up;
-
The extent and toxicity of residues are unclear. Residents
are commonly advised to remove food, medications, cosmetics,
and medical devices. This appears to be “informed guess”
advice; there is no truly authoritative information on whether
other household items such as clothes, bedding, upholstery,
and carpets also retain residues, in what amounts, or for
how long.
-
The warranty for Vikane treatment is generally only 2 years,
the same as for alternative treatments. The toxicity of
the pesticide does not translate into a longer period of
termite-free living for you.
|
- Drywood
termites, do not need much moisture and can infest any wood
they get access to;
- Subterranean
termites, which infest decaying wood that is within reach
of the soil;
- Formosan
subterranean or dampwood termites.
|
Drywood Termites
-
Don’t have wood in contact
with soil.
-
Cover exposed wood
with paint or sealer.
-
Remove wood debris
from your yard.
-
Plant trees away from
house, and prune away vegetation that provides a bridge to the house.
-
Ants are predators
of termites. Do not kill ants that are not causing a nuisance problem
in the house.
According to Sheila Daar
and William and Helga Olkowski, " The most permanent, most effective
and safest treatment of the problem at the most reasonable cost may
require a careful integration of activities carried out by the homeowner
and a number of experienced professionals [ such as carpenters] from
more than one company." 2
These are the nontoxic or least-toxic
options that may be incorporated into your strategy:
Drywood Termites
-
Removal or repair
of infested wood. For a small infestation, this may be all that
is needed.
-
Heat: This involves
tenting and heating either the whole structure or just a part of
it up to 140 degrees Fo, a temperature that will not
harm the structure. A test of termite eradication methods at UC
Berkeley in 1996 resulted in a 100% mortality of termites in naturally
infested wood boards treated with heat.3 Care is required
to remove all household items that may be damaged by heat, such
as electronic equipment.
-
Microwaves: this
is a spot treatment method that also kills the termites by applying
heat. The researchers cited above got a 100% mortality rate with
this method as well, applied to naturally infested boards. Other
studies have had varying success rates. House damage may include
warped wood and wood burns.
-
Cold: cold treatment
with liquid nitrogen is a spot treatment method whose effectiveness
ranged from 74 to 100% in the above tests, depending on the dose
used. This can be an effective method for inaccessible areas, as
nitrogen is injected through small holes drilled into the walls.
Frost formation within the house may damage some wall coverings.
Drill holes must be repaired. NOTE: as of
spring 2004, we do not know of any companies that offer this treatment
-
Electrocution:
Called Electrogun, this is a spot treatment using volts of electricity,
which kills termites in exposed wood. Mortality in the above tests
was 95% four weeks after treatment in naturally infested wood. Drill
holes and minor wood burns may result from the Electrogun method.
-
Borates:
Borate salts or boric acid can be injected into wood as a treatment
or applied to wood surfaces as a preventive measure. Borate dust
may be used in wall voids as well. Borate foam is another form of
borate that may be applied as a spot treatment. Depending on the
product and treatment method, borates may act as a contact poison
or a stomach poison. Borates should not be used on wood in contact
with soil, as they are water soluble and will leach into the soil.
Tim-Bor, Bora-Care, Jecta, and Impel are some brand names of borate
products. Ethylene glycol may be added to liquid formulations of
borates; this substance increases the penetration of the borate
into wood but may be a problem for chemically sensitive individuals.
- Borates are also
available in over-the-counter products for people who want to do their
own termite treatments. An example of a product available in San Diego
area home improvement stores is Spectracide Terminate. According to
the manufacturer, the product comes in a dust formulation for injecting
into cracks and crevices in exposed wood areas, and in a water-based
spray form that can be applied to bare wood. The spray will penetrate
the wood, whereas the dust must be squirted into existing cracks,
or else into holes that you drill (1/8 inch drill bit, drilled 1-2
inches deep, 3-4 holes in a square foot). The kill rate is 100% in
24-48 hours for all termites it comes into contact with. As with all
spot treatments, the difficulty is in knowing whether you’ve reached
all the termites. Continued surveillance may be needed.
-
Fungal pathogens:
BioBlast is the trade name of a method that utilizes a fungus that
is deadly for termites when sprayed onto the infested wood.
-
Limonene or other
citrus derivatives: Limonene has been used successfully as a
pet flea control agent, and is now being applied to termite control.
No information was found regarding the effectiveness of this method,
whether it provides residual protection, or to what extent it is
found in the indoor air of structures treated with it.
- Pyrethroids,
a class of insecticides that originally derived from chrysanthemums
but now are manufactured synthetically. Examples of pyrethrins used
in products licensed for termite control in California are bifenthrin,
cyfluthrin, cypermethrin, deltamethrin, esfenvalerate, permethrin,
and prallethrin. Piperonyl butoxide is often added to pyrethrin products
to increase their effectiveness. Pyrethroids used for termite control
have moderate acute toxicity. Several are possible carcinogens or
suspected endocrine disruptors. See table below.
- Imidacloprid
is the active ingredient in some brands of spot-on flea products for
dogs and cats, and is found in other insecticides as well. Premise
is a current brand used by exterminators. (There is another pesticide
product called Premise which contains pyrethroids, so make sure you
know which product is being considered for your house, if an exterminator
plans to use Premise.)
Neither borates nor fungal pathogens
was tested in the Lewis-Haverty study cited above, so their effectiveness
cannot be directly compared to the other drywood termite treatment
methods. Both of them provide some residual protection against reinfestations,
whereas fumigation, heat, cold, and Electrogun do not.
PYRETHROID
TOXICITY |
| Pyrethroid
Registered in California for Termite Control |
Acute
Toxicity* |
Carcinogen |
Endocrine
Disruptor |
| Allethrin,
d-trans
|
Unknown
(parent compount has moderate toxicity |
Unknown |
Suspected |
| Bifenthrin |
Moderate |
Unknown |
Unknown |
| Cyfluthrin |
Moderate |
Unknown |
Unknown |
| Cyfluthrin,
beta |
Unknown |
Unknown |
Unknown |
| Deltamethrin |
Moderate |
Unknown |
Unknown |
| Esfenvalerate |
Moderate |
Not
likely-EPA |
Suspected |
| Imiprothrin |
Unknown |
Unknown |
Unknown |
| Permethrin,
mixed, cis, Trans |
Moderate |
Possible-EPA |
Suspected |
| Prallethrin |
Moderate |
Not
likely-EPA |
Unknown |
| Pyrethrins |
Moderate |
Likely-EPA |
Suspected |
| Tralomethrin |
Unknown |
Unknown |
Suspected |
- All
toxicity information in this table is taken from the PAN Pesticide
Information database. We thank PAN for putting this very useful
database out for the public to use. Http://www.pesticideinfo.org.
The PAN database uses question marks to indicate when there
is not sufficient weight of evidence information to make a
toxicity determination.
- Acute
toxicity is usually measured by the LD50, the dose that is
lethal to a group of lab rats. The lower the LD50, the more
toxic the chemical. “Moderate” here means an LD50 of 50 to
500 milligrams of pesticide per kilogram of body weight.
|
|
Subterranean
termites
-
Pyrethroids:
pyrethroids are less acutely toxic
(poisonous) than Vikane or Dursban. However, Several are
possible carcinogens or suspected endocrine disruptors.
See table above.
-
Nematodes:
certain species of nematodes attack insects rather than
plant roots and can be used for subterranean termite control.
-
Sentricon/Recruit
II is a Dow Agrosciences product that consists of a
termite bait containing an insect growth regulator, hexaflumuron.
The product is designed to used as part of an integrated
pest management system and sold as a service, not over the
counter. Hexaflumuron can cause irritation to eyes or skin
but had low toxicity to rats who ate it or breathed it in
laboratory studies. It is highly toxic to aquatic life and
should not be used in low areas or near water sources.4
-
Termidor
is another relatively new product for subterranean termite
control, to be used only by licensed termite exterminators.
It contains fipronil, a phenyl pyrazole type of pesticide
that kills by disrupting nerve transmission. It is irritating
to eyes and skin, and is toxic by all routes of exposure
(skin contact, breathing, ingestion). The acute toxicity
of fipronil is moderately high, based on lab rat studies
(97 mg/kg ).5
The toxicity of the finished product will depend on the
concentration of fipronil in it. Chronic toxicity studies
show it is harmful to the nervous systems of both rats and
dogs. It is classified by the United States Environmental
Protection Agency as a possible human carcinogen based on
thyroid tumors in rat studies. It is toxic to aquatic wildlife
and should not be used in low areas or near water sources.6
-
Premise,
containing the active ingredient imidacloprid (mentioned
above), is also used for subterranean termite control. The
acute toxicity of imidacloprid is low to medium (450 mg/kg
body weight in rats). It is not considered to be a cancer-causing
substance. Feeding studies in which imidacloprid was given
to rats or dogs at high doses showed some developmental
effects, thyroid, or liver effects. It has a very low vapor
pressure, which makes it unlikely to evaporate from soil
and into the air where you might breathe it. It is toxic
to birds, bees, and aquatic invertebrates. It should be
kept out of water sources.7
|
| San
Diego Area Companies That Provide Termite Control Alternatives |
Company
|
Estimated
percent of termite control services that do not include
Vikane |
Methods
Used for termite Control |
Preventive
treatments offered? |
Spanish
speaker available? |
Agricultural
Pest Control
800-696-8565 |
30% |
Microwaves
Whole
house heat
Dursban
Repair/Replacement
Vikane
Termidor |
Yes
|
No |
American
Pest Control
800-287-7321 |
50-60% |
Borates
(Timbor)
Cy-Kick (cyfluthrin)
Dragnet (permethrin)
Vikane |
Yes |
No |
Dewey
619-588-1550 |
<
10% |
Heat
(whole house and local)BoratesVikane |
Yes |
Yes |
Ecola
818-920-7301 |
87% |
Borates
Heat
Electrogun
Limonene
Microwaves
Vikane
Termidor
Premise |
Yes |
Yes |
Hi-Tech
Termite
888-869-9992 |
90% |
Microwaves
Termidor
(fumigation subcontracted out) |
Yes |
No |
Hydrex
800-735-7378 |
90% |
Borates (Timbor)
Electrogun
Microwaves
Heat (local)
Limonene
Repair/Replacement
Vikane |
Yes |
Yes |
Stock
Exterminators
800-339-1679 |
60-70% |
Borates
Heat (whole house and local)
Sentricon/Recruit (hexaflumuron)
Termidor (fipronil)
Vikane |
Yes |
No |
Xtermite
877-300-6483 |
100% |
Borates
(Timbor)
Limonene
Repair/replacement
Sodium chloride
Imidacloprid |
Yes |
Yes |
|
What
to ask
As always, it is important to be an alert
consumer, and to get everything in writing. In particular:
-
For how long will the
company guarantee their work?
-
Do they use any back-up
chemicals for spot treatment? Will they provide you with Material
Safety Data Sheets and product labels for any chemicals they plan
to use?
-
Will they put it in
writing that they will not use any materials other than those you
have agreed to?
Consumer
Information on San Diego Termite Treatment Companies
|
Company |
California
Structural Pest Control Board record* |
Minimum
Guarantee of Work Done** |
| Agricultural
Pest Control |
Licensed
since 1991
No complaints in the last 2 years |
1
year |
| American
Pest Control |
Licensed
since 1972
No complaints in the last 2 years |
1
year |
| Dewey |
Licensed
since 1985
No complaints in the last 2 years |
No
information |
| Ecola
Services |
Licensed
in San Diego since 1994 4 complaints in the last 2 years |
2
years |
| Hi-Tech
Termite |
Licensed
since 1997
2 complaints in the last 2 years |
2
years |
| Hydrex
Pest Control |
Licensed
since 1980
13 complaints in the last 2 years |
2
years |
| Stock
Exterminators |
Licensed
since 1989
2 complaints in the last 2 years |
1-5
years (varies with treatment method) |
| Xtermite |
Licensed
since 1998
8 complaints in the last 2 years |
1
year |
* The California
Structural Pest Control Board provides information on complaints
made about the companies in the last two years. These records apply
only to the San Diego branches of these companies and cover the
two years preceding August 2004. We suggest you make your own calls
before hiring a company: the number is 800-737-8188.
** This information is derived from written questionnaires sent
to the companies by EHC; those who did not respond may have satisfactory
guarantees but we do not have the information.
Let Us Know About Your Experience!
We would like to hear from you if you have used
any of the companies listed here, or others in the San Diego area.
Were they courteous and informative? Did you get all your questions
answered? What method(s) did you use, and how effective were they?
Did you need the company to make return trips, and were they willing
to come? What did they charge? Your responses can help other San Diegans
in the difficult position of having to choose a company and a pest
control method. Call us at (619) 235-0281 or email to JoyW@environmentalhealth.org
References
1. Northwest Coalition
for Alternatives to Pesticides, 1997. "Alternatives: Drywood
Termites," Journal of Pesticide Reform, Winter, 1997,
P.22.
2. Olkowski, W., Daar,
S., and Olkowski, H., 1991. Common-Sense Pest Control, p.429.
Newtown, CT: Taunton Press.
3. Lewis, V.R., and Haverty,
M.I., 1996. "Evaluation of Six Techniques for Controlling the
Western Drywood Termite Incisitermes Minor (Isoptera: Kalotermitidae)
in Structures." Journal of Economic Entomology, Volume
89, number 4, pages 922-934.
4. Dow Agrosciences, 1999.
Material Safety Data Sheet for Recruit II Termite Bait, Product Code
51794.
5. World Health Organization,
International Program on Chemical Safety, 2002. The WHO Recommended
Classification of Pesticides by Hazard, and Guidelines to Classification,
2001-2002.
6. Aventis, 2001. Material
Safety Data Sheet for Termidor SC Insecticide Finished Spray Solution,
Product Code 432-901.
7. Extension Toxicology
Network, no date. Pesticide Information Profile on Imidacloprid. Available
online at: http://extoxnet.orst.edu/pips/ghindex.html
Return to Top
| Return
Home | Contact
EHC | Action
Alerts | Join
Us | Search
|